I thought it was ... bizarre that no thread had been opened for this wonderful movie yet. I do believe it deserves one, if not for true discussion, at least to advertise it. It definitely holds a very high place in my list of favourites: this movie is clever, poignant, romantic, surprising and has got OUTSTANDING music.
It also belongs to those films one feels the need to talk about after watching it; the problem is, there's no way to talk about it without spoiling the plot, and spoilers here would be particularly annoying, given the "secret".
Following, some infos about the movie:
Secret (traditional Chinese: 不能說的秘密, literally "The Secret That Cannot Be Told"), is a 2007 Taiwanese romance film. It is the directorial debut feature film of Taiwanese musician Jay Chou, who also stars as the male lead and co-wrote the movie.
Ye Xianglun (Jay Chou), a music student majoring in piano, transfers to Tamkang (Danjiang) Secondary School. It is a school famous for musically talented students, especially in piano. On the first day of school, as he wanders through the piano building, he hears a mysterious melody being played that leads him to Lu Xiaoyu (Kwai Lun-mei), another piano major. When he asks her about the song she was playing, she tells him that it is a secret that cannot be told. The two develop a relationship that is clouded in mystery.
Has anyone seen it? Did you like it?
:)
It also belongs to those films one feels the need to talk about after watching it; the problem is, there's no way to talk about it without spoiling the plot, and spoilers here would be particularly annoying, given the "secret".
Following, some infos about the movie:
Secret (traditional Chinese: 不能說的秘密, literally "The Secret That Cannot Be Told"), is a 2007 Taiwanese romance film. It is the directorial debut feature film of Taiwanese musician Jay Chou, who also stars as the male lead and co-wrote the movie.
Ye Xianglun (Jay Chou), a music student majoring in piano, transfers to Tamkang (Danjiang) Secondary School. It is a school famous for musically talented students, especially in piano. On the first day of school, as he wanders through the piano building, he hears a mysterious melody being played that leads him to Lu Xiaoyu (Kwai Lun-mei), another piano major. When he asks her about the song she was playing, she tells him that it is a secret that cannot be told. The two develop a relationship that is clouded in mystery.
Has anyone seen it? Did you like it?
:)
This was one of the first asian movies I had actually watched. I was introduced to Jay Chou in my Chinese class 4 years ago haha. His music at least. So after seeing he was the lead actor in this movie I wanted to watch, and I'm so glad I did! I keep wanting to rewatch it, it's one of my all time favorite movies. Brilliant, I loved the piano music, too! I'd recommend this movie to anyone!
Love this song! :D
SPOILER video
Love this song! :D
SPOILER video
I started off watching a not so great video & audio quality link which was a bit off putting but YouTube saved the day yet again lol
The film had a “quiet” & understated feel about it. It felt like nothing was happening but of course it was. The piano playing was amazing & the "duel" that was probably my favourite part about the film. I also like the father he was a bit wacky I loved that he made his son dance the tango with him haha I would so do that if I had kids ……I would definitely be an embarrassing parent.
Spoiler ---> I knew straightaway that she couldn’t be seen by others & thought she is a ghost & thought ok thats a cliche story line (I guess I have been inured to such cinematic ruses since The Sixth Sense :) ) but I am glad to say I didn’t anticipate the time travel twist so that was good. The ending what happens did they manage to meet up or did he “see” someone else before he found her & therefore would be invisible to everyone else……the last frame of the movie I couldn’t really make out who was in the picture, so that left some unanswered questions for me. Do they live happily ever after ? I hope so! <------
all in all a very good effort by Mr Chou!
The film had a “quiet” & understated feel about it. It felt like nothing was happening but of course it was. The piano playing was amazing & the "duel" that was probably my favourite part about the film. I also like the father he was a bit wacky I loved that he made his son dance the tango with him haha I would so do that if I had kids ……I would definitely be an embarrassing parent.
Spoiler ---> I knew straightaway that she couldn’t be seen by others & thought she is a ghost & thought ok thats a cliche story line (I guess I have been inured to such cinematic ruses since The Sixth Sense :) ) but I am glad to say I didn’t anticipate the time travel twist so that was good. The ending what happens did they manage to meet up or did he “see” someone else before he found her & therefore would be invisible to everyone else……the last frame of the movie I couldn’t really make out who was in the picture, so that left some unanswered questions for me. Do they live happily ever after ? I hope so! <------
all in all a very good effort by Mr Chou!
RainRosie wrote: I started off watching a not so great video & audio quality link which was a bit off putting but YouTube saved the day yet again lol
The film had a “quiet” & understated feel about it. It felt like nothing was happening but of course it was. The piano playing was amazing & the "duel" that was probably my favourite part about the film. I also like the father he was a bit wacky I loved that he made his son dance the tango with him haha I would so do that if I had kids ……I would definitely be an embarrassing parent.
Spoiler ---> I knew straightaway that she couldn’t be seen by others & thought she is a ghost & thought ok thats a cliche story line (I guess I have been inured to such cinematic ruses since The Sixth Sense :) ) but I am glad to say I didn’t anticipate the time travel twist so that was good. The ending what happens did they manage to meet up or did he “see” someone else before he found her & therefore would be invisible to everyone else……the last frame of the movie I couldn’t really make out who was in the picture, so that left some unanswered questions for me. Do they live happily ever after ? I hope so! <------
all in all a very good effort by Mr Chou!
To answer your question: he kept on living in her time, seen by everyone I guess, as suggested by the photograph he's in at the end of the movie. That's how I interpreted at least. :)