Trágico
Vamos lá para minha primeira critica, depois de assistir esse drama eu precisava desabafar.Se você gosta de dramas aqueles bem sofridos, não liga muito para detalhes, vai em frente e assista.
A historia tinha tudo para ser boa, quando li o resumo logo me interessei, porem no primeiro episodio já me senti desanimada com vontade de pular algumas partes e dai foi só ladeira a baixo, Não ligo para clichês , porem esse drama exagerou demais nos clichês no drama em tudo; e por mais triste que a historia era não conseguiu me prender pois tinha tantos defeitos no roteiro nas atuações, na produção em si que foi difícil de me conectar.
Por falar de atuação ,a protagonista atuando e uma porta não tem diferença nenhuma, ela não tinha expressão nenhuma não passava nada ,nem mesmo chorando me senti comovida de tão ruim foi a atuação dela. O casal perdeu um grande tempo de tela juntos em questão de romance.
Quero destacar também a péssima trilha sonora, meus ouvidos sangraram , a todo momento aquela musica dramatica interrompia a história com aqueles flash de memorias e quando não era isso os efeitos sonoros grotescos vinham atrapalhar a conversa dos personagem a musica que era para ser de fundo tomava conta do nada e fica super alta e a conversa séria que estava acontecendo ficava de fundo junto com seu interesse em continuar. De todos os defeitos nesse drama a trilha sonora me irritou mais. Eu nunca tinha me deparado com algo tão grotesco assim, já assisti 75 doramas e nunca fiquei tão desapontada nunca assisti algo tão mal feito. pra mim não salvou nada, nada me agradou nesse drama, realmente foi uma decepção.
Meu Deus como sofri para assisti esse drama, juntei todas minhas forças para não parar de ver.
Em fim foi sofrido , mas assisti e não recomento nem para o meu pior inimigo. desculpem a sinceridade mais foi essa minha opnião.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Worst FL Ever
This drama was so Meh!! I watched b/c of Vaness Wu and he was alright here but this may have been too much for him to carry the show. Plus he couldn't deliver the gravitas needed for the characters's anger moments it all seemed so tame when the character has every right to be angry.A lot of stuff happening in this series defies logic and usually I can suspend belief b/c I want the romantic fantasy and live for it but this did not deliver the goods AT ALL!!
I hate the FL and have never hated a FL more. I will never understand her motiovations after the fact just dumb. I also hated her doe eyed dumbfouned face everytime she asked to tell the truth but kept lying. Will never watch this again. Liked Xio Le but really not a fan of super precocious kids but he was likeable.
Terrible ending; Guang Xi shoud have gone to the US and taken Xio Le with him. YEP I'm a hater!!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
The story starts with how a young girl called
Mu Cheng becoming an orphan and had to live with her former fathers wife boyfriend as they were rendered bankrupt, her step mothers boyfriend staring developing sexual interest in her as she grew older and made her start feeling uncomfortable in the Sheng university quarters they lived , she tries in every way to avoid him as she they all work in the canteen that serves students food along with her aunt at the Sheng university.
Ren guan xi is a troublesome law student whose family owned and managed the Sheng university for, he remembered his father dying of suicide while young and concludes his mother made his dad die and resents his mum and always caused trouble for he to fix, he met mu cheng while he was causing trouble as always and finds out after making a bet with his friends that she is the only girl that has proved herself unavailable to the boys at Sheng university as she never gives them attention or a number, he decides to follow through the bet to make her kiss him in less than 24 hours , he forces her on a date threatening her that he would report her friend Tuo ye of lending out a book to a non university student, she caught on and made a fool of him saying she had also made a bet with other students to make him kiss her too. Mu Cheng leaves home angrily on that day and finds herself in Sheng hall building where quang xi goes to reminiscence of his time with his father there, she saw a piano there and begins to relive her younger days as a pianist and plays a tune quang xi recognizes, he ends up telling her to strip for him to embarrass her and her tears whilst trying to strip moved him and they gradually began a friendship, he becomes more protective of her when he sees that her step father had suspicious abusive behaviors towards her; so he got closer to her and later fell intensely love with her to the point of getting serious as a law student when an accusation of her selling her body was spread in the school, he defended her reputation on a panel and won.
But tragedy strikes as he fainted and later was diagnosed of brain tumor with only a 15% chance of survival, he harshly breaks off with mu Cheng until he hears she was in danger working at a fish market and he rushes off to see and eventually rescues her, they got stuck together in her house and ended up staying the night together having sex, the next day quang xi decided to go for the surgery so long as Mu Cheng stays with him, but with only the hope of 15% survival and a higher chance of 30% survival If his family accepts a deal with another rich family with the hope or marrying their daughter Yi Quin. Mu cheng had no choice than to play along and eventually cruelly leaving his side during his operation even though he ran out after her and saw her leave with her friend Tuo ye while being stabbed by her step father.
The operation was successful however quang xi wakes up with lost memory of his past and all his cognitive abilities and only Yi quin by his side whilst Mu cheng moves to Hua village, a community known for growing flowers, she found out she had become pregnant for Guang xi and gave birth to a most adorable boy named Xiao Le.
After 6 years, quang xi had to relearn everything with the help of Yi quin and passed his bar exams with no memory of the past, he became a notoriously good lawyer and was planning on marrying Yi Quin who had stayed by his side. During one of his sexual assault cases a memory of him defending Mu cheng flashed of his past which made him beat up his client and he was sentenced to 240 mins of community service of legal service at Hua village .
Guang xi arrives the village and immediately meets the adorable boy called Xiao Le who calls him his alien dad, and also saves mu cheng from a man forcefully trying to drug her to force marriage on her. He unknowingly formed a familiar bond with mother and especially his son not knowing who she really was, he returns to Taipei as a changed man after winning a case against his future father in law and the people of Hua Village, his new moral behavior became suspicious to his family as he had always been know to be a lawyer who acted without hai conscience, until his family found out he had met Mu cheng again when Xiao Le runs away from home to look for Guang xi.
Guangxi recovers his memory on the eve of his wedding with the help of a memory card inserted into the leather bracelet he gave Xiao Le, he breaks off his wedding and immediately wanted to torture everyone who kept him in the dark about his past life , he also immediately wanted Sole custody of his son Xiao Le, out of jealousy he also forced Mu Cheng to marry him because of her close friendship with Tuo ye, guang xi kept misunderstanding Mu cheng’s loyalty to Tuo ye and made him crazily jealous to the point of almost divorcing his newly married wife Mu cheng, until Xiao Le their son pulled them back to each other forcing them to acknowledge their feeling for each other.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Who likes love story with little bit melodrama ,so this a right choice
Every part of the drama was perfect .expressions were amazing . Every actor was amazing . especially kiddo ,that child acting win my heart . He was so cute and his dialogue delivery was too good. So naturally his expressions were coming out ,too good. So smoothy story is went . Though it has 32 episodes but story was so good that it had not realised that it has 32 episodes .Good part of the drama that it didn't portrait bad image of male lead's mother . Second male lead is also good . Love triangle always made little bit sad when both side have genuine feeling .so felt little bit bad for second male lead character . I had watched 2009 year drama in 2022 year ,time is so changed but still I like the story . So I highly recommend it
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
There are many different kinds of love - and they are all love
I really liked this series. A thought provoking look at love, self sacrifice and betrayal, and the many shades of grey that blur the lines in between until one turns into the other.I liked the characters and the actors who portrayed them. They were perfect choices. The chemistry between the leads was beautiful and felt genuine, and the side characters were developed nicely too. I found the story compelling.
I totally disliked the cringey whining of the main song, and found it annoying as it was played so often, but I turned down the volume and overlooked that weakness because everything else worked so well.
Yes it has a lot of the typical drama tropes but there was an extra level of thoughtful character development that made it feel relatable and real.
This is certainly the best Taiwanese drama that I have watched, and will likely rewatch., so I do recommend it.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Full of miscommunication, but I still enjoyed it
Let me start by saying that I usually HATE time skips, and I was so terrified of this one that I watched up till the time skip and paused the drama for four months because I couldn't bring myself to continue.But I liked this a lot more than I expected. For someone who usually hates noble idiocy and lack-of-communication as plot points, the storyline was serious enough for me to really empathize with Mu Cheng and understand why she did what she did, especially considering how fleshed out her backstory was.
There were a lot of scenes that were really heartbreaking, even frustrating to watch, because it felt like nothing ever went right and the story was just so tragic and angsty. At the same time, however, there were really adorable and pure scenes between the main leads, and like everyone else, I grew to love Xiao Le as well, who quickly became one of my favorite characters ever.
Yes, part of me wished the characters were just more open and honest with each other, as it felt like ALL the characters did that "lie for someone else's own good," but Autumn's Concerto managed to pull it off. I also commend the drama for tackling sexual assault/abuse AND how perpetrators often get away with it—it felt too REAL.
I won't lie, some of the things Ren Guang Xi did were REALLY problematic, but considering how much character depth he actually had and the other ways sexual assault was addressed, I'm willing to let it slide.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
Mélodrame classique , fille pauvre, garçon riche, maladie, amnésie, enfant amour,amour,amour...
Ce fut mon deuxième drama taïwanais après « Mars », et comme j’adore les (bon) mélodrames, je me suis régalée avec celui-là.Il y a maintenant quelques années que je ne l’ai pas revu, ce qui a été fait au moins trois fois quand même !
C’est toujours la même vieille histoire du garçon riche et assez insupportable et de la fille pauvre, belle et méritante… Mais quand c’est bien raconté, ça passe très bien, et ici c’est très bien raconté, les personnages sont intéressants, bine construits avec suffisamment de facettes pour ne pas tomber dans la caricature ! Il y a le triangle habituel : la fille, l’amoureux, l’ami amoureux sans espoir… Mais là un adorable gamin vient s’ajouter, apportant une part supplémentaire de sentiments, de secret, de chagrin et de joie à l’histoire. J’avoue que mes passages préférés sont ceux où Xiao Le s’accroche à Guang Xi, finissant par pénétrer dans son cœur presque par effraction, puis à bien s’y installer ! C’et un mélodrame, c’est à dire qu’on joue tout le temps sur la corde sensible : un amour que rien n’efface, les malentendus et les quiproquos indispensable aux scènes où on partage intensément l’injustice du sort des héros, même sis pas une seconde on a douté de la fin ! Mais quand on a affaire à un bon mélo, on joue le jeu à fond, on ne demande que ça ! On adore se laisser prendre, rire et pleurer avec les héros, et partager leur bonheur du happy end final !
Les acteurs sont très bons les trois principaux mais aussi les gens du village, la famille de Guang Xi et le scénariste n’est pas tombé dans piège de faire une vile morue de la fiancée, au contraire, elle a un très joli rôle !
Bon, c’est un drama déjà ancien, taïwanais, avec une image un peu grenue et les idéogrammes défilent de temps en temps sur le côté de l’image, et il faut accepter que les sous-titres en chinois soient tout le temps présent. La musique n’est pas mal du tout mais malheureusement elle est tout le temps à, les quelques morceaux passent et repassent, ce qui fait qu’à la fin ils nous sortent par les oreilles (enfin à moi ! ) même si le thème du jardinier est une jolie chanson…
Si tout ça ne vous arrête pas, vous avez là un excellent drama, mélo pur sucre, mais où tout est si bien dosé, si bien écrit et joué que c’est un régal !
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
É um bom drama, mas temos que relevar algumas coisas.
Decidi fazer a minha resenha após ver por aqui outras detonando o drama.A maior crítica que vi nas resenhas é com relação aos clichês.
Sim, esse dorama é recheado de clichês, mas isso não o torna necessariamente ruim.
Temos que levar em conta algumas questões antes e julgar a história. Esse drama é de 2009. Por volta de 2010 os dramas com temática de doença estavam em alta. Muito em alta.
E nem todos tinham um final de "felizes para sempre".
O drama traz algumas temáticas fortes, tais como o abuso familiar, a dependência financeira, machismo, entre outras.
Ainda hoje é difícil encontrar doramas que tenham como um dos plots a gravidez quando mais jovens.
Parece meio que um tabu, como se as mulheres asiáticas não se envolvessem sexualmente antes do casamento.
Concordo com que disse que achou a protagonista chata. Também não gosto muito dela, mas o carisma do Vanness Wu nesse drama consegue amenizar isso.
Outro ponto que me incomodou foi a quantidade de obstáculos que a protagonista coloca no caminho. Ela se auto-sabota. O drama se arrasta por algumas vezes e não existe um grande conflito que justifique a separação dos protagonistas.
Depois dessas críticas vocês devem achar que não gostei do drama. Pelo contrário : gosto muito.
A melhor coisa de todas é a interação do Xiaong Li e seu pai.
É muito fofo! Só isso valeria a pena assistir.
Outra coisa deliciosa de se ver é o amadurecimento do personagem principal.
Se você gosta de clichês, doramas com crianças, segunda chance no amor e amadurecimento de personagem, dê uma chance a Autumn's Concert.
Provavelmente irá gostar.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
1. Thoughtful dialogue: You actually wanted to sit through long monologues and watch the tension unfold between two characters. You actually did not want to throw a chair at the screen. You might even shed a tear. It was well done.
2. Addicting story line: This is a highly addicting, binge worthy show. My husband was able to sit and binge watch this show with me over a weekend.
4. Good use of flashbacks: Flashbacks usually suck in most dramas. In this case, the realistic style of the flashbacks (short bursts of selected scenes) aided in the tension. It made the scenes better.
I do have to criticize the overuse of the same soundtrack throughout. I can still hear it in my sleep.
Overall, this is a highly addictive, well written, romantic drama that takes you on a journey and leaves you feeling changed afterwards. There aren't many shows out there that can do this so don't hesitate and watch now.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
What could have been.
I know i’m not familiar with Taiwanese dramas as I am with Korean, but bear with me as I felt they followed the same formula to a certain extent. Keep in mind that Autumns Concerto was released one year after Boys over Flowers. So it’s hard to gauge the impact it had on this series, if it had any at all. This is all before the “me too” era. To cut to the chase, this drama had so much freaking potential, but by the middle half, it goes completely bonkers.There is so much to digest here, and there might be a few spoilers, but there was just so much wrong with this show. The main character forces himself on the female lead at least 4-5 times. So much is glossed over, as if it’s normal. There’s attempted kidnapping, murder, attempted rape, prostitution, and so much more. All of this seems normal, despite little consequence until we get to the 30th episode where things get more absurd.
The FL almost never expresses a full thought that bears emotion and weight with what she’s faced in life. She’s frail and timid, never allowing herself to say what’s on her mind. This starts to change, a little bit, but I kid you not, by the 29th episode. The formula every single character uses then, especially the FL, is to lie. And boy does everyone lie. Lies upon lies, upon withholds. We never get complete answers from the FL, no matter who asks, especially when it mattered. The solution is to keep lying while thereby creating more needless drama. During 2008, I think producers and writers felt that this kind of path gave the viewers an inclination to keep watching. This doesn’t work in the digital age and I don’t think it did much then either. If you watch only the first 10 episodes of this series, you could say it’s almost among the best. The brain tumor storyline was done insanely well, but it’s the only saving grace.
So many of the extra side characters are useless. The “best friend” male is an utter train wreck of a character. He has no money. No title. No completed education. Instead, he tries to solve real world problems with his fist and manly facial expressions. It’s almost a joke by the 29th episode. At one point a character says this exact line, “I don’t know how to explain how absurd all of this is.” A line used by the ML’s would be wife, who decided to keep a recovering amnesia patient in the dark so she could have her happy fake fiancé. By the time you reach that line, you realize how fitting it is to tie the whole series down.
If it weren’t video speed pro, I wouldn’t even had bothered.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
