Not having been a huge fan of Taecyeon in Dream High, I watched this drama strictly for the plot. It sounds neat: A girl who discovers she can see ghosts after a 6 year coma and a guy who helps her solve her ghostly mysteries. I'm not saying the plot line should win a Pullitzer or anything, but it does sound entertaining! Unfortunately, this drama squandered all of that fun potential on pseudo plot twists and mediocre romance.
It's never a good sign when you root more for the lead character to be with a ghost than you do the actual male love interest. Surprisingly, this isn't even Taecyeon's fault! I was really impressed with how much he had improved from Dream High, and I really did love his character. Cha Gun Woo is an all-around good guy, willing to help out our heroine even when he isn't sure if he believes her. But even though he was doing all the right things, there was just no chemistry between him and Yang Shi On.
Yang Shi On's character was, for the most part, fairly likable. It was hard not to feel for her when she was so obviously lost and confused, trying to pick up the pieces after a 6 year absence from the world.
Kim Jae Wook was easily the star of the drama, which is interesting considering that for the majority of it, he didn't have any lines. But the way he watched over Shi On and loved her so much, even after so long was just heartrending.
The villains were disappointing, never evil enough to really be interesting, nor frightening. I can't even count the number of times that Gun Woo and Shi On were able to outmaneuver huge groups of men. If two people, with one of them having just come out of a coma, can beat 20+ gangsters, you are obviously not hiring gangsters from the right place.
Other than convoluted plot lines and a sad attempt at emotional terrorism in an effort to make you connect with the characters, this show isn't wholly irredeemable. It's short episodes ensure that you don't feel too bored throughout, and for the most part the ghost's problems were fairly interesting. All in all, not a complete waste of time.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha pode conter spoilers
This drama surprised me by keeping me interested. When I first started this, I wasn't sure if I would like it. It is a mix of supernatural and mystery. There is one big overall conspiracy mystery and little mysteries along the way. I know that some people may find the ending anticlimactic, but I enjoyed it. Like most people, I feel like Kim Jae Wook as Lee Hyun Joon stole the show. He has an important role and I think he played it well. It is hard to write a review without spoilers. So, I will just write that I thought his ending was appropriate. He did what he thought was important and that was all he needed. So Yi Hyun was good as Yang Shi On, but I don't think that she is the best actress. Some people find Taecyeon lacking because he is an idol actor. However, I thought he was witty and cute as Cha Gun Woo. If it weren't for him acting with So Yi Hyun, then I don't think I would have finished this. I actually thought he pulled her up. The other actors are good too. I liked seeing Kim Ye Won again as Jang Hee Bin. I wonder when she will get a main role?
The music isn't anything I remember.
I may rewatch this if I am looking for something light to watch.
This is not horror. I didn't find it scary at all. If you like mystery (although, I think to a certain extent most people will figure things out quickly) with the mix of supernatural, then I recommend this drama.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Taecyeon is remarkable in his easy portrayal of characters, and I've been impressed with him since Cinderella's Sister and Dream High. I was excited to see what he could do with Cha Gun Woo, and he didn't disappoint. He's got a lot of spunk, for sure, and thinks a little too highly of himself, but he goes to incredible lengths to protect those he cares about. Cha Gun Woo's character goes through the emotional wringer throughout this series, and Taecyeon pulls it off with flying colors.
His chemistry with So Yi Hyun, by the way? Crackling. As is Yi Hyun's chemistry with Kim Jae Wook. Basically it's a bowl full of crackling, heartbreaking chemistry where you just don't know where your allegiances lie until the last possible moment. Of the three, Kim Jae Wook impressed me the most, though--his character is given very few lines in the first half of the drama, but he carries his scenes with a finesse that tells of his acting experience. As I'd only seen him as a supporting character before, I was impressed by the sheer amount of dynamism he brought to his role.
The music is lovely, too, and I find myself humming the ballad insert song "Because Love Grows" all the time.
I will say the series is a bit slow to pick up, but once it does it takes off like a shot. For example, when Yang Si Ohn first starts seeing ghosts, she freaks out EVERY. TIME. It gets to the point where you kind of want to just shake her and go "how is this still surprising you??" We also don't discover much about her backstory until later in the series. But once again, the build up is palpable and well worth the wait--everything is tied together, and I felt my heart clench with each new reveal.
Even side characters in this series (like Cha Gun Woo's subordinates or his superior, Moon Shik, the hacker he blackmails into doing his dirty tech work--and Si Ohn's friend and spiritual advisor Hee Bin) steal their scenes with either cuteness or masterful acting. I never felt like I was sitting through a filler moment.
If you're looking for an action packed crime thriller, Who Are You isn't it. It's a nuanced look at the small-time cases of the Lost and Found center, and the dramatic rediscovery of Yang Si Ohn's memories. While there are fights, and losses, they are not the beating center of the story. Instead, I really liked the concentration on the relationships between the characters, and how major plot points affect them. Who Are You was well worth the wait.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
The main cast was very good. I tend to love Kim Chang Wan, Inspector Choi Moon Shik, in everything he does. He's an entertaining, scene stealing, and versatile actor who never fails me. This was my first time seeing Ok Taec Yeon. He was good. He played his character effortlessly and was very appealing. I even liked So, which is a first. She usually annoys me. Again Kim was excellent. He had very little interaction and because of his character he did most of his acting from the shoulders up. Every movement was done with purpose and it worked. The supports were also well cast.
The music was mostly forgettable and if I ever hear that love song again it'll be too soon.
I will probably never watch this again. I have no reason or wanting to, but it was worth a watch. It could have been much much better, but it also could have been that much worse. I should really give this a 6, but the cast is better than that. Too bad the script wasn't as good.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
I really really liked this drama. I would lie to if I said I started watching it because of the plot, I actually started watching it because of Taecyeon. I have seen him in other dramas and I really like his acting, the fact that he's super handsome just makes it all even better.
After watching the first episode I was hocked. I just wanted more the moment it ended and it was a pain waiting a whole for two more episodes but at the same time that just made it all more exciting.
So what did I like about it all?
First I have to mention the story. I didn't think it was gonna be so deep as it actually was. Thought it was gonna be more like a detective drama were they solved cases with the help of the ghosts she sees but that wasn't the case. You figured out it was gonna be a lot about their past and what comes with it.
The actors did a really good job. Taecyeon and So Yi Hyun had really good chemistry. I also really like the small "sidestory" between the other cop and the shaman girl. Really looked forward to see how it would end between them.
So overall, this is one of the better dramas I've and I have seen way to many... Absolutely worth watching, even if you're not a fan of Taecyeon!
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Though opening with an auspicious premise, execution is shaky at best. Cliches and obvious plot contrivances riddle the story with holes. Because Who Are You attempts realism even while necessitating the suspension of disbelief on other fronts, some token of veracity should be offered. Unfortunately, no venue ever offers this oasis. Police elements felt silly at best, but as a second poorly handled aspect (the coma) forces writers to realize it as such, a vicious cycle begins. The ghosts manage to be the most acceptable, though somewhat unimpressive, part. In the face of such stumblings, some interest remains at the heart of the main plot line. What happened to Lee Hyun Joon? This question acts as the life preserver which keeps everything else afloat.
It should not surprise then, that Kim Jae Wook owns the entire stage. Given little to say and few interactions to make, his Hyun Joon speaks volumes with the slightest gesture or expression. Many will fall for this character, and who can blame them? Everything riveting about Who Are You links back to him. Leads Taecyeon and So Yi Hyun work passably with people far less fascinating. Gun Woo, though a reasonably nice person, appears to have little life outside the events of the drama; Shi On barely feels like a police officer, let alone valedictorian in her year at the academy. And her series-launching coma...yikes. For all it affected her, they may as well have written it out.
Of the entire soundtrack, very little is memorable. Trickyneko provides one underused piece, “Our Story,” which sets a pleasantly spooky atmosphere.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
The cast did a pretty good job with this plot even though sometimes the main female actress seemed inconsistent. However I found actor Kim Jae Wook as "Lee Hyun Joo" refreshing to watch. (Even if he didn't have many speaking parts.)He was definitely the character I anticipated to see more of as the episodes went by.
Overall everything seemed pretty decent even though the ending I could have lived without.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Good writing, right there!
Ok Taecyeon and So Yi Hyun make a wonderful duo with great chemistry. And I especially enjoyed Taecyeon’s acting performance, he has come a long way since Dream High. Yi Hyun is brilliant as well, I enjoyed seeing her playing a "serious" character and not just the sweet love interest. Although she went a bit over the top with the crazy-eyes, she’s definitely a new favourite. Kim Chang Wan is fantastic, he plays his role with such finess it's scary. His reference to Iljimae was just... flawless. X)
The supporting roles were a bit bleak, but with the time frame they had I guess it was expected. And I'm glad they stayed focus on the main story and characters. This is one of those dramas where the ending is very, very important and I was quite nervous that they would lazy-wrap it, but they didn't. It was a great finish for a great drama.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Although Taecyeon is cute but I'm still in Kim Jae Wook team;))
Not a best choice if you're looking for something cheerful, it's definitely not in that category.
Weekest point: music
I started watching "Who are you" while watching Master's sun and everybody knows how amazing Master's sun was so it's difficult to get a very good impression of something with kind of similar plot.
I was really interested in the story for the first 8 or 9 episodes but after that story line and romance just got a bit boring. I wanted to finish it after 3 or 4 months of break and the only impression I had about this drama was that it had one good kissing scene (Yang Shi Ohn and Cha Gun Woo) and a ghost that leaved a huge impression.
And that's probably because of Kim Jae Wook that I watched this drama to the end. Somehow his sad eyes and his expression were so heartbreaking that I just felt uneasy and wanted to see how it would turn out.
So I think that all the glory for this drama still leaving a good impression on viewers despite many lacking points should go to Kim Jae Wook. If it wasn't for his amazing acting it wouldn't be that unforgetable.
And when it comes to week points, for me the weekest point of this drama was music. I've been wondering for quite a lot of time why I cannot watch this drama to the end and I've figured out that it's not necessarily because of bad plot or lack of chemistry between main leads. It was because of music. It made whole drama so gloomy and I don't want to say that it shouldn't be that way cause it's still a ghost story but honestly if the music was just a bit more epic in the moments when it should be and more romantic when the scenes required it, some really nice scenes wouldn't be wasted.
Music is so important because it brings up emotions and it makes a lot of scenes more memorable but 1 or 2 good songs are not enough to make you keep watching.
But still it's quite worth watching, but I don't recommend you to watch it at the same time as dramas with similar plots.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Story:
The story sounds nice, a girl who sees ghost and she and her partner go to help those ghosts and by the way save and solve some crime cases.
It was nice and interesting at first when she helped those dead people but after she helped them and the storyline went for the past it was less good for me.
Althought it was interesting all along for me, it didn't bore me until the last episodes so that was the good point.Also there were things that I was surprised by them.
Acting/Cast:
I know the actors as good actors so I didn't understand why they act so badly in here, a lot of times I found myself saying" what is it with the script, their chemistry isn't good and they can't express their feelings well" so I think the good point of the drama is Kim Jae Wook. Not only the actor who did a good job in this but also his character was the best in there, I didn't empathize with the main characters (Tae Cyeon and So Yi Hyun) and I found them a bit childish or not intersting, even annoying.
The good part of the characters were the supporting ones that gave a bright feeling to this, and their little stories were funny/more interesting than the main characters.
Music :
I didn't find it remarkable, the main song is like an every-drama song.
Romance:
The main issue of the drama wasn't romance which I like that fact, but the romance part that we saw didn't move me emotionaly , it felt awekward and showed the fact that they didn't have chemistry .I thought that Yi Hyun and Jae Wook had a better chemistry and they looked better with each other.
Rewatch Value:
I wouldn't watch it again, it wasn't a "good" drama and it wasn't made well, it was a nice drama to pass time.
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
Esta resenha foi útil para você?
