A Love So Beautiful (2020)

Short, simple and to the point

I did not hate this drama, I didn’t exactly like it either, it was fine for what it was, and while not surpassing the original it still has its merits. As a fan of the original I have no gripes with it, well I do have some criticisms that also apply to the original but ill reserve those for my review of the original.
So first lets go into the things I liked; the length, I like how its short and to the point, it doesn’t drags on and it’s easy to watch, I liked the main leads, I really enjoyed the two side characters they added, they’re really fun to watch and have a lot of fun scenes, the songs where very nice, I really liked them.
Now for the things I didn’t like, it was too short, while this is a good thing so the drama doesn’t feel dragged out like in the original, it made it feel rushed in a lot of things, many things didn’t have as much of an in impact, it also lost a lot of the charm and awkwardness of high school that the original had, the side characters weren’t as good, mainly the two best friends, they had so much charm and personality in the original but they just don’t have it in this remake, the struggles of being at the verge of entering adulthood and having to go through high school and dealing with teachers and parents that is perfectly encapsulated in the original just isn’t here.
Over all I actually quite enjoyed it despite all its short comings, it really could’ve benefited from a longer run time, but I actually like how short it is it, maybe they could’ve made it 30 min eps instead of 20 min eps, if you haven’t watched the original I can’t say you’ll enjoy it because I don’t know how it stands on its own, and if you’re a fan of the original you might not like this adaptation because all the changes made to it, but I liked it and recommend it if you want to watch something short, simple and to the point.

Leia Mais

Se este é um "Amor lindo demais" não imagino como a humanidade sobreviveu...

Pensei em escrever em inglês para abranger mais leitores, mas teria que pensar mais neste drama e, realmente, o sofrimento do seu visionamento já me é suficiente.

Após ler algumas resenhas, ainda mais surpreendido fico. Então, este amor é lindo demais?

HISTÓRIA
Temos Sol Yi, uma estudante cheia de vida e com um sorriso simpesmente doce, capaz de agregar toda a esperança do mundo, que gosta loucamente e de uma forma linda e inocente de Cha Heon. Este é um aluno com excelentes notas, tão carismático como uma barata (mas não a de Kafka), com uma expressividade e emoções iguais à de um boneco de teste de colisão e que me recorda aquelas atrizes que se enchem de botox e de plásticas, em que sorrir é uma impossibilidade fisionómica.
Supostamente, no final, ele diz que gostava dela há imenso tempo. Na realidade, sempre a teve por perto, ignorando-a, e cuidando dela como um banqueiro cuida das nossas contas bancárias e o Estado dos nossos impostos.
Blábláblá, os anos vão passando, com grandes amigos e com momentos carinhosos e divertidos que me fizeram continuar a ver. No meio disto, procurei a relação entre os dois (pior que "Onde está o Wally?), em que o ser fantástico, mais romântico que uma linha de programação do Holo (de "Holo, meu amor"), continua a aparecer perto dela. Depois vem a universidade e começam a namorar. Aí, o namoro é tão belo como Tonto (o amigo fiel do Mascarilha) e o seu cavalo, ou o Rantanplan e Lucky Lucke (ou mesmo os irmãos Dalton)...
Em que local do mundo poderá essa personagem considerar que a ama quando vota na sua adversária para líder da turma, não lhe dá boleia quando ela perde a bicicleta, não oferece ajuda nos estudos (só em último caso, e no fim de todos aqueles anos), mas ajuda outras pessoas, etc. Nem quero imaginar o que faria se não a amasse...
Depois de a ignorar durante a universidade, evitando vê-la, perguntando porque apareceu sem avisar, etc. (parece crer que é o único estudante do mundo ocupado), resolve ir para os Estados Unidos (ou seria na Coreia do Norte, onde não poderia entrar em contacto? Que saudades Park Hoon!, "Doutor Estranho"). Aí, nos Estados Unidos, recorde-se!, sem manter qualquer contacto com o seu, suposto, grande amor, nem com os amigos por sinal, permanece durante 3 anos, para depois regressar à Coreia.
Na Coreia, continua o grande amor que nos informará, a posteriori, que sente (ainda bem que o faz pois não tinha notado), mas esquece-se de contactar com ela. Mais uma vez, uma síndrome, como no Drama W, deve ter surgido e, quiçá, estivessem em universos paralelos (deve ter sido um paralelo de estrada que atingiu fortemente o sistema límbico no cérebro de Cha, que controla as suas emoções) e por isso deverá ser difícil na Coreia ter rede.
Passado um certo tempo, reencontra-a de uma forma fortuita ("obrigado pai por adoeceres!", terá Sol Yi pensado) e... viveram felizes para sempre. Um pedido de casamento (já vi mais emoção em pessoas famintas a pedir comida na fila de um qualquer estabelecimento de "fastfood"...), e uma reação dela a dizer que sim.
Este drama transcende-me, quer na forma como os relacionamentos coreanos parecem ser (viva a relação, apesar de um pouco possessiva, entre Jin Hwan e Ha Young), quer na maneira como os beijos parecem ser tão entusiasmantes como lamber um pedaço de lixa ou beber um shot de lexívia. Se os Coreanos e Coreanas beijassem qualquer latino(a), sul-americano(a) ficariam imediatamente apaixonados...
Mas voltando à história.... parece-me que o pedido de casamento, mais uma vez tão belo como um derramamento de petróleo, teve lugar sem que o casal maravilha tivesse passado de um beijo... Imagino que por volta dos 30 anos cortem as unhas do outro e aos 40 anos tomem duche ao mesmo tempo. Espero que consigam fazer amor antes que ele tenha problemas de ereção e que ela entre na menopausa...
Que saudades do relacionamento amoroso entre King Kong e Ann Darrow.

ATUAÇÃO - a atuação foi decente, adorei a So Joo Yeon, o seu sorriso torna qualquer dia soalheiro. A exceção é o Chucky, o boneco diabólico (desculpa-me Chucky!) do ator (ahahahahah!, ator...) Kim Yo Han.

MUSICAL - nada de extraordinário...

VOLTAR A VER - só se fosse como Yorick Brown, da novela gráfica "Y - O último homem", e tivesse que, a bem da sobrevivência da espécie rever esta série.

NO GERAL - pela sinopse, parecia algo interessante, com um amor belo que, para mim, foi unilateral e tortuoso. Se este é o conceito de amor vigente, aí sim eu entendo porque os casamentos e a taxa de natalidade estão a decrescer vertiginosamente...

Leia Mais

Didn't think I would like this so much !

When I saw that A love so beautiful was gonna be adaptated in korean I was really happy as I liked the chinese version and its story. When I saw the teaser though...I was not that excited, I felt like it was a basic web drama like we have a lot !
Since netflix decided it to put it on its platform and the episodes were just 20min, I decided to give it a go, just to have a real opinion, and I am glad I did.
I will try my best to not review it by comparing it to the chinese one, because it would be unfair in my opinion as I really enjoyed both of them for different reasons. Obviously there are some things that need to be said, and when watching, you cannot help but compare.
The main point is that the 2 dramas are quite different IMO, expect for the story and its character of course, but the whole mood is really really different. I felt that this version was a lot more fluffy, cute and funny. The chinese one was more serious and "mature". Also, the male lead was much more likeable in this one, less stoic and showing much more interest for the girl, which bothered me in the chinese one.

I think the actors did a great job portraying their character. I don't know Kim Yohan (yes I am what we call an old Kpop fan and don't really follow all those new groups) but he was quite good in his role and I didn't feel cringey with his acting. As for Ju Yeon, I knew her from Dr Romantic 2 where I really liked her. I wasn't really convinced at first as she doesn't really look like a High schooler but as the story follow them until adulthood, it didn't borther me more than that. Them together were really cute and I felt their chemistry.
I enjoyed watching the rest of the friends and got attached to every single one of them, I really felt like they were a bunch of friend enjoying their youth. Ji hwan made me laugh so much and every girl should have a boyfirend as caring as him !
The story followed the original one so I knew what was coming next. They cut some parts as this drama is shorter but they still manage to give us the main stories. It did feel rushed sometimes and for someone who doesn't know anything about the story, some reactions may seem weird but I liked that they went straight to the point with no useless scenes. The episodes went really fast and managed to keep me engaged until the end. I will not talk about what their didn't do well as it will give spoiler but let's just say the chinese version took more time to explain more deeply the characters choices and mindset.
I really liked the OST, it was cute. My only downside is the last episde, I wish they would give dae sung some air time to end his story well, as he was a big part of this drama.

Overall a really cute drama. Definitly not something that I will remember for years but I spent a really good time watching it and had a smile on my face every episodes. I would recommend it for people who just want a cute story, with no superfluous stories and attaching characters.

Leia Mais

Loved it

Honestly I loved it it was so cute it made my heart flutter all the time. Sol I was so cute and cheerful that it was honestly amazing to watch I loved her character Heon was cute and I loved how his character development and how he realized his actions He was cute and sweet he really cared for her.daesung was an amazing character too he was soo sweet although he grew up in a not so good household I loved his friendship with sol I and how he called her brother was also cute. Hayoung threw me off at first cause she liked a teacher but I loved her character overall she motivated sol I and protected jaehwan she was a funny character and I’m happy she ended up with jaehwan. Jaehwan was hilarious tbh the way he had a crush on hayoung was so cute lmao he was hilarious always made me laugh. Overall I loved the ending it was so peaceful and relaxing to watch I loved this drama so cute and peaceful something I needed I see a lot of people saying the cdrama was better but I like this one more I feel like the characters are better portrayed by the actors in the kdrama like sol I’d actor played her perfectly I couldn’t see another way same goes for yohan , daesungs actor,hayoung actor and jaehwan’s actor

Leia Mais

Predictable, Silly, But Cute Series!

If you're looking for something fun and light, you really can't go wrong with "A Love So Beautiful." Frankly, there have been better shows involving a girl who falls in love with a boy where the girl (for some reason) isn't very bright compared to the object of her affection. "Good Morning Call" and "Mischievous Kiss: Love in Tokyo" are better series.

This is a story that has been done a number of times, although the twist toward the end finally gives it some brand of uniqueness despite knowing how it's going to end. Not all shows that are predictable are necessarily bad.

Shin Sol-Yi is a young, passionate girl, who's quite naive and also very immature for her age. Unfortunately, this doesn't really change as she gets older. She starts out as a 17-year-old girl, acting like she's 10. She ends as a twenty-something woman acting like a 12-year-old. She whines and pouts, and too often this becomes a little annoying.

I've lived and worked in China, Korea, and Taiwan. And I've told people: take the girl's age and subtract ten years to get her true maturity. It rarely fails.

Cha-Heon is the object of Sol-Yi's affection. He's the top student, but he's a bit cold and aloof when it comes to Sol-Yil and her more than obvious interest in him.

The performances are pretty good. Yo-Han Kim (Cha-Heon) is a bit wooden in his role. So Ju-Yeon (Shin Sol-Yi) has the cutest dimples in the world and a million-dollar smile to boot. I only wished that she'd been able to bring more depth and dimension to her character as well as giving her character a bit more maturityj to make her more appealing and less annoying.

The kissing scenes in this show are some of the worst I've ever seen. Wooden, tight-lipped with absolutely no feeling or authenticity at all. It was quite obvious that the actors and actresses did NOT like doing them.

Still, this is a fun series to watch. It's nothing too special, but it's a solid feel-good story that will likely put a smile on your face.

Leia Mais

A much needed lighthearted series

I've seen the Chinese version and liked it. But for me, I prefer the Korean version. In terms of acting and story pacing, it's better.

I like how the male lead in this version was portrayed. Yes, he can be cold but you could also see emotions underneath his exterior. He's not as robotic as with the original. Also, the cast has great chemistry with each other. I can totally see them as a close group of friends. And since the episodes are a bit short, there was no draggy moments/storyline.

Overall it's a fun watch if you want something light and fun.

Leia Mais

I tried...

Let me start this faithful and very late review. The college has been trolling me and so time is of the essence.
Before you ask, yes, I will discuss which of the two versions I like better but LATER. For now, I shall appreciate it as its own thing.
Let me start with the story. It really is a story of life, youth, and time. Things happen to the main character that changes her world view whether it is realizing that it can't always revolve around a boy or that certain things take responsibility and she needs to be held accountable. As for being a remake, I love some changes and I thought some others were better left alone. Some scenes kept did not have as much impact as the original and some scenes changed both fell flat and brought the bomb. There was variety :) The beginning was especially rushed and fast-paced due to the difference in episode count but I did feel that they could have done a better job. After around ep 3-5, the story worked itself out and got back on pace. True to the original but able to make it its own :) got to love it.
The Acting and Cast? I loved it. There was no moment where I thought :/ or really wished someone else took the roles. What else is there to say? I felt that I could tell by looking at the character and the way they all spoke which their Chinese counterpart was. I feel that is one of the greatest compliments to a cast for a remake. I also enjoyed the dynamic and watching them really dawned on me new possibilities because I couldn't really imagine a new cast up until that point.
The OST? I will be singing it all day. It was actually what initially attracted me to watch the show other than the original. Whenever the song came up I was tapping my feat, humming along and my head swayed without my knowledge at times. This one song alone probably had more impact than most things. It was very enticing and really kept me watching. I still listen to it. I actually can't pick between this version or the original version of the song but it was a nice throwback surprise.
uhhh as for rewatching value...I actually gave it a 7 because it seems like a rewatch friendly show but I haven't rewatched it soo I can't really judge it quite ye. I haven't done a review for the original so I might rewatch both at one point to have a better opinion.
Overall, as a stand-alone it was great.

Now, THE STATEMENT of which I liked better.
It doesn't matter because I like both!! Like or dislike is a preference that has no bounds, if you want to discuss which one is objectively better as a critic, go ahead but preference is a number of things. There is really no winning no matter which one you liked more. I get flamed for liking the new one and I get flamed for liking the original because people think I am biased. Nostalgia is a factor, my dudes. Don't flame someone cause they liked whichever one more for whatever reason. Doesn't devalue or opinion or anything so why does it matter. It is not like you are gonna agree with them and turn a new leaf. haha, I apologize, a bit too charged for my taste but I needed to say it.
Which one would I watch again first? The original. Does that mean I like the original more? I don't know. If you really want an opinion, just watch it and form your own. It was a good show on its own and it managed to be a good remake as well. The original will always hold a place somewhere on the popular drama wall and people liking this remake more won't change that.
My opinion on what was better for each category :
OST: Korean
Story: Chinese
Actors: Tie

Leia Mais

Muy mala, pero adictiva y divertida de ver.

Me gustaría empezar diciendo que, aunque le di un 7, considero que esta serie es mala, malísima. Está llena de clichés, las relaciones amorosas no tienen sentido, hay muchas escenas cringe... Pero es tan mala que llega a ser buena a veces. Por eso considero que la volvería a ver, porque hay momentos que son demasiado *icónicos*, al menos en mi opinión.

La actuación está bien. Es cierto que algunos personajes actúan de formas exageradas e irreales en algunos momentos, pero considero que ese es un error de guion más que un error de actuación. Los personajes me parecían a veces un poco estereotipo y esperpénticos pero, exceptuando al prota masculino, no creo haber odiado a nadie. Woo Dae Sung me cayó bastante bien, la verdad.

Otro factor importante para mi disfrute es que lo vi con amigas. Poder quejarnos de lo que veíamos juntos mientras hacíamos coñas mejoró mucho la experiencia.

En conclusión: si tienes amigos con los que echarte unas risas con esto, no pierdes nada por ver la serie. Si quieres ver una comedia romántica que no te haga tirarte de los pelos de la frustración, entonces esta no es para ti.

También decir que no sé nada de la serie china. Por lo que he leído en reseñas el protagonista masculino está mejor construido, lo cual me alegra porque es que aquí no hay por donde cogerlo.

Leia Mais

cute and short but maybe not the best remake

Honestly I've never written a review but I thought I should write one for this drama.
I first watched the korean version before I watched the original, but so far I've rewatched both of them more than two times. The korean version lacked the depth in characters and in story-telling, and overall I feel like the plot was just cut down. You can barely see the development in the relationship between the ML and the FL, their moments together literally go by so fast. Where as in the c-drama, you can see their feelings grow and change.

Moreover the actor for the FL just looks older than the character should. No matter how they tried to make her appear younger, whether that was through her short hair or making her behaviour so-child like and immature, I felt like the actress didn't really connect with the role and she wasn't really able to bring out her character until the end of the show. (no shade to the actress though shes gorgeous but its just a case of bad casting lols)

And the thing that bothered me the most was how she would forgive the ML so easily. When he told her she was a loser, or when he was caught with Heeji. He would never directly apologize. Like how does playing the piano and telling her 'dont go' when she's thinking of transferring equivalent to an apology? LMAO like okay he could be bad with words and displaying what he feels but this literally makes no sense. You get a sense of his true feelings and some of the reasons behind his actions in the last episode but thats practically it. Overall I feel like this could've been better but its cute for what it is.

Leia Mais

No recomiendo

Sólo lo terminé porque por alguna razón, estaba entretenido y me mantenía viéndolo. Pero me desesperé viendo las decisiones que ambos protagonistas tomaban.

Por un lado, la obsesión de Sol Yi con Cha Heon, no soportoooo. Qué necesidaaaad?

Me gustó que la historia muestra su historia con el paso de los años, pero faltó más comunicación y amor propio por parte de los protagonistas.

Cha Heon estaba ya tan acostumbrado a Sol Yi que pasaba tiempo con ella y ni le hablabaaaaa, qué incómodo era verlos juntos sin dirigirse palabra alguna.

Innecedarismente largo, falta de comunicación, obsesión y decisiones cuestionables por ambas partes.

Leia Mais

A Love So Beautiful (2020)

The show's a little unrefined, rough around the edges, and at times iffy at best but its got the spirit and that's what counts.

I always felt that the coming-of-age genre is a cheat code in writing since many can easily relate to its thematic values. So essentially the show was playing with house money but doesn't quite act like it. The story progression and pacing is a bit of a mess and uncoordinated. It makes safe but bland choices which, when paired with the fact that secondary characters shined a bit brighter than their primary counterparts, resulted in a safe but bland experience.

Still, the show is easy on the eyes, easy on the mind, and easy for viewers to digest as we watch a love blossom into something so beautiful.

Leia Mais